ElijahStanfield.com
  • Politics

We Need More Regulations!

7/13/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture

Libertarians are often accused of promoting unregulated chaos. I admit there are some libertarians who don't fully understand how building, pharmaceutical, and food regulations might work without government intervention. All they know is "Regulation bad" according to the rhetoric they've been exposed to. But the truth is that we actually do suffer from a lack of regulation. The problem is that these regulations are written and enforced by government. I'll try to explain why this is a bad idea and what some of the unintended consequences are when government plays the role of regulator.

Conflict of Interest
When the government writes and enforces aggressive legislation and regulation, called positive law, it supposes itself to have the power and authority to play an active role in molding society by political force. But the reason for the creation of governments in the first place was for defensive purposes - negative / natural law. A government cannot participate in creating positive laws without breaking negative laws. 

"...the purpose of the law is to prevent injustice from reigning. In fact, it is injustice, instead of justice, that has an existence of its own. Justice is achieved only when injustice is absent."

                                                                                                             -Frederick Bastiat

In this contradiction of purpose comes chaos and corruption. If it is accepted by the people that government should be involved in positive law making, everyone will look to advance their personal well-being through the political means. When government is the regulator, a door is open for people and corporations to seek to seize that power in order to dominate over their competitors and protect themselves from risks in the market. Is it a surprise that corporations spend millions to lobby lawmakers? 

Government Regulation Protects Businesses From Liability
Poorly constructed buildings, dangerous medication, and hormone filled foods are serious problems, but it should be recognized that all of these horrible things have been highly regulated by government for decades. They have been approved as "safe" by government regulation. You see regulation, when mandated by government, actually legalizes a certain amount poison in food. It legalizes drugs and immunizations that can kill you. The worst part is that because they have been approved as safe, the guilty parties are pretty much free of liability because as long as they have met the regulatory standards they are not at fault.

When a business is not directly accountable to its customers, they have no incentive to improve the quality of their products and services. Risk of getting sued is the greatest motivator for caution. Government regulations remove that risk and responsibility, resulting in businesses acting reckless and irresponsible.

Government Regulatory Services Are a Subsidy to Big Business
Why is it that we have tax funded building departments? Why are tax payers giving free safety inspections to dairy farmers? Why aren't pharmaceutical companies paying for their own third party test trials? Sure they might pay an occasional small fee, but these departments are not supported by these fees. The staff, building and vehicles are funded by people who may not ever use their services. 

A Solution For More, Stricter Regulations
There is no reason why these government service industries shouldn't be privatized and fully funded by their customers- just like any other business. If the burden of liability for the safety and quality of products was placed on property owners and those they contract with we would see an increase in regulation. Businesses would be extremely careful about the safety of their customers out of fear of legal action. Businesses that provide quality and safety inspections would be incentivized by the same fear as their property owning clients. They would be paid to check for safety issues and if they fail, they would be at fault.

Pharmaceutical companies would make cleaner vaccines. Milk and meat would be hormone and poison free and buildings would be built to a higher standard. Some may think this is naive thinking, but again government has already been regulating these things and the result has been that we have lower , not higher, standards of safety, enforced by law. 
1 Comment
Linda
9/28/2015 10:40:20 am

Joseph Smith is famous for stating that he teaches correct principles and allows his followers to govern themselves. The problem with regulations (government regulations) is that they do great harm to all those who must abide by them, without any voice in whether they are the correct remedy to the problem, whether they are even constitutional, or whether they are supported by the majority, which would be determined by voting on those matters.
Tyrants are created by regulations.
Take RideShare for example. They are regulated by the open marketplace. Do crappy business, get rated by your customers, lose any future business you might have gleaned.
With government regulation, no one has a say as to whether the cost is worth it. We all lose then.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About the Author

    Elijah Stanfield is a media producer in Washington State. He has received degrees from The Delaware College of Art and Design and the Rhode Island School of Design. 

    A longtime student of Austrian economics, history, and the classical liberal philosophy, Elijah has dedicated much of his time and energy to promoting the ideas of free markets and individual liberty. Some of his more notable works include producing eight videos in support of Ron Paul's 2012 presidential candidacy and providing Illustrations for The Tuttle Twins series of children's books. 

    He currently resides in Richland with his wife, April and their 6 children.


    Topics of interest:

    Mormonism
    Economics
    Freedom
    Ethics 
    History
    Family
    Media Production
    Food


    Recommended Websites:

    Political
    Connor's Conundrums
    Stefan Molyneux
    Tom Woods Radio

    Religious
    The Life of Jesus Christ
    The Rebel God
    Rock Waterman

    Media Production
    FreeSound.org
    Audio Jungle
    Lens Pro to Go
    Dafont
    What the Font?
    Identifont
    Video Copilot
    Video Hive
    Brands of the World
    Philip Bloom

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.